Which Water Filter is Right for Me & My Home?

Last Revised: 3/7/25

Does your water have a funny smell or taste? Do you find stains on your sink, countertops, and dishes? If so, it’s time to take action – clean water isn’t a luxury, it’s a necessity.  

Water should be clear, clean, and safe – but for many homeowners, that’s not the reality. If your water smells like a swimming pool, leaves stains on your sink, or has particles floating in it, then you may want to prioritize testing your water quality and installing a water filter system.  

Testing once every few years is always advisable, and it’s the first step towards finding the right filter that fits your home’s unique challenges. It can also give you peace of mind as some of the most dangerous contaminants can’t be seen or tasted. 

“ 

In some cases, the best solution isn’t just one filter – it’s a combination of different systems that each address a different aspect of your water quality. 

” 

At Mattioni, we’ve been helping homeowners get high-quality water for over 75 years. We understand that no two homes are the same, and neither are their water problems. Whether you’re dealing with bad taste, scale buildup in your pipes, or potentially hazardous contaminants, we can help you choose the perfect solution.  

In this article, we’ll dive into the most effective water filtration and conditioning systems available and cover which contaminants each system addresses. After reading this, you’ll be prepared to make a confident decision about your home’s water filter needs. 

What’s Really in Your Water? Why Water Quality Testing is Essential  

Have you already conducted a water quality test? Click on the contaminant you’re facing for the filter or conditioning system best suited for you:  

• Foul Taste or Odor 
• Chlorine and Chloramines 
• Heavy Metals (Lead, Arsenic, Mercury, Copper) 
• Particles (Dirt, Rust, Sand) 
• Bacteria, Viruses, and Cysts 
• Fluoride 
• Low pH 
• Hard Minerals (Calcium, Magnesium) 

Most people assume their tap water is fine, but the truth is that even public city water can contain contaminants that affect your health, plumbing, and appliances. For instance, chlorine and chloramines are often added to disinfect water but can give it an unpleasant taste. Hard minerals like calcium and magnesium are also common, and while they don’t pose a direct health risk, they can wreak havoc on your home.  

Do you have well water? If so, the stakes are even higher. Bacteria, viruses, and heavy metals like iron or lead are known to pollute private well water. 

So how do you know what’s in your water? Testing is key. At Mattioni, we offer professional water testing to help you identify exactly what’s in your water. We provide personalized recommendations for water filtration and/or conditioning systems that solve your home’s specific challenges. Testing is the first step towards cleaner, healthier water. 

Now let’s jump into the best water filter options and find the perfect one for your home. 

Water Filtration Systems That Transform Your Water Quality 

Activated & Catalytic Carbon Filters  

If your water has a strong chlorine taste, and earthy odor, or just doesn’t seem fresh, a carbon filter could provide all the filtration you need. These filters are excellent for improving taste and smell by trapping common contaminants like chlorine, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and some heavy metals. 

Standard activated carbon filters absorb impurities and are commonly used in pitcher filters, under-sink systems, and whole-house units. Catalytic carbon filters take things a step further by targeting chloramines, a chemical disinfectant that many municipal water systems use. Chloramines are harder to remove than chlorine and can contribute to plumbing corrosion and health concerns over time. If your home is on city water and you’ve noticed a persistent chemical taste, a catalytic carbon filter might be a good place to start. 

Big Blue Sediment Filter 

For homeowners with well water or visible debris in their tap, a Big Blue Sediment Filter acts as a powerful first line of defense. Sediment buildup can clog appliances, damage plumbing, and leave your water looking cloudy or discolored. This type of filter is designed to trap dirt, rust, sand, and other particles, preventing them from making their way into your home’s water supply. 

One of the key benefits of the Big Blue Sediment Filter is that it protects other filtration systems from clogging. At Mattioni, we include it as the first step in our Well Water Conditioning Package. If you’re considering a reverse osmosis or Seagull IV filter, the Big Blue Sediment Filter ensures those systems operate efficiently by removing large particles beforehand. Think of it as a bodyguard for your home’s water quality. 

Seagull IV Filter 

When it comes to producing high-quality drinking water, the Seagull IV Filter is a standout. Originally designed for travelers and boaters needing pure water on the go, this system is now a top choice for homeowners who want safe, chemical-free water without sacrificing essential minerals. Unlike some filters that strip everything out, the Seagull IV maintains healthy minerals while removing bacteria, viruses, and other harmful contaminants. 

If you’re looking for an easy-to-install, low-maintenance solution that delivers exceptional water quality, this could be the perfect fit. It doesn’t require electricity, storage tanks, or a complicated installation – just clean, pure water on demand. 

Reverse Osmosis (RO) Filter 

For those who want the purest drinking water possible, a reverse osmosis (RO) system is also at the top of the list. This technology forces water through a semipermeable membrane, filtering out up to 99% of contaminants, including lead, arsenic, fluoride, and even certain bacteria and viruses. If you’re worried about potential toxins in your tap water, this system provides peace of mind. 

While RO systems are extremely effective, they do have some drawbacks. They remove beneficial minerals along with contaminants, which is why some models include remineralization. Its filtration process produces some wastewater, although modern systems have become much more efficient. For homeowners prioritizing clean, contaminant-free drinking water, reverse osmosis remains one of the most trusted solutions. 

Water Conditioning Systems That Protect Your Plumbing System 

Filtration alone isn’t always enough. You may be struggling with hard or acidic water conditions that can lead to scale buildup and corrosion in pipes and appliances. In these cases, water conditioning systems should be prioritized instead of (or in addition to) a water filter. 

Neutralizers 

If your water supply has low pH, meaning it’s acidic, a neutralizer is the ideal choice for you. Over time, acidic water can eat away at metal plumbing, leading to pinhole leaks, metallic-tasting water, and costly plumbing repairs. A neutralizer works by introducing limestone, which is slowly dissolved into your water, increasing its alkalinity and stabilizing its pH. Neutralizers are effective at reducing the aggressiveness of your home’s water and protecting your plumbing system, appliances, and surfaces. 

Water Softeners 

A water softener is a must-have for homes with hard water. If you’ve noticed white, chalky residue buildup on your faucets, stiff laundry, or dry skin after showering, hard water is likely the culprit. Water softeners use ion exchange technology to replace hard minerals like calcium and magnesium with soft ones like sodium and potassium. This helps prevent scale buildup and improve the efficiency of water heaters, dishwashers, and other appliances. Soft water also extends the life of your plumbing, saving you from expensive repairs down the road. 

Choosing the Right System (or Systems) for Your Home 

Every home’s water situation is unique. Some homeowners just want to improve the taste of their tap water, while others are dealing with serious plumbing issues caused by hard or acidic water. In some cases, the best solution isn’t just one filter – it’s a combination of different systems that each address a different aspect of your water quality. 

The Big Blue Sediment Filter is often installed as a pre-filter to protect other conditioning systems. A carbon filter can improve taste while the Seagull IV filter removes bacteria, and a neutralizer balances pH while a water softener prevents scale buildup. You can see how installing more than one system can be a worthwhile investment. 

That’s why Mattioni offers the City Water Conditioning Package and the Well Water Conditioning Package, each specifically designed to address the common challenges of both water sources. 

Our expert water testing and tailored solutions ensure that you get the right setup for your needs. Whether you need a single system or a multi-layered approach, we’ll help you find the perfect combination to keep your water clean, safe, and hassle-free. 

We’ve been trusted for over 75 years to provide honest, high-quality service, and we’re ready to help you find the perfect water filtration or conditioning system. If you’re tired of second-guessing what’s in your water, schedule a consultation today and take the first step toward cleaner, safer, and better-tasting water. Call us at (610) 400-8510 or book online – because healthy water is an essential part of our everyday life.